@bliv91 Pennsylvania

When Shanahan looks at two very, very dangerous hits, how does he weight 20 games vs. 40 vs. 50 etc.? Without scale, incredibly difficult.

8:20PM Mon, May 07 2012

@chrispeak1

But there is nuance and context within each hit. To pigeonhole discipline is to ignore the details that separate the violations

8:21PM Mon, May 07 2012

@bliv91 Pennsylvania

This would be tantamount to determining power play length based on the violation. Simply unfair.

8:22PM Mon, May 07 2012

@shickshinny

Didn't you call people who said he would get suspended, idiots?

8:22PM Mon, May 07 2012

@DoctrSteveBrule Pittsburgh

@chrispeak1 its easier to pigeon hole and spew fallacy in 136 characters and get a rise out of people. Let him do that.

8:23PM Mon, May 07 2012

@chrispeak1

No, I'm not advocating eye-for-an-eye; hate when people advance that notion. I'm saying each hit deserves independent appraisal

8:24PM Mon, May 07 2012

@DoctrSteveBrule Pittsburgh

@937TeenWolf Exactly! if the Weber hit never occurred and wasnt screwed up by Shanny, then there would be no argument

8:28PM Mon, May 07 2012

@bliv91 Pennsylvania

No. Define scale (e.g. https://t.co/uaxKtktI ) then prescribe punishments for each.

8:29PM Mon, May 07 2012

@bliv91 Pennsylvania

@chrispeak1 Stuff like that is going to happen over and over again. Hell, even Giroux/Neal were "pigeonholed" to an extent

8:30PM Mon, May 07 2012

@DoctrSteveBrule Pittsburgh

@chrispeak1 So the NHL should base all future decisions on past mistakes?

8:31PM Mon, May 07 2012

@bliv91 Pennsylvania

@chrispeak1 They shouldn't make the mistakes.

8:32PM Mon, May 07 2012

@DoctrSteveBrule Pittsburgh

@chrispeak1 well they happen, that doesnt mean that in the future every decision has to be another mistake...

8:33PM Mon, May 07 2012

Anonymous

Replyz collects and amplifies questions from around the web, allowing a wider audience to answer them.

When Shanahan looks at two very, very dangerous hits, how does he weight 20 games vs. 40 vs. 50 etc.? Without scale, incredibly difficult.

But there is nuance and context within each hit. To pigeonhole discipline is to ignore the details that separate the violations

This would be tantamount to determining power play length based on the violation. Simply unfair.

Didn't you call people who said he would get suspended, idiots?

@chrispeak1 its easier to pigeon hole and spew fallacy in 136 characters and get a rise out of people. Let him do that.

No, I'm not advocating eye-for-an-eye; hate when people advance that notion. I'm saying each hit deserves independent appraisal

@937TeenWolf Exactly! if the Weber hit never occurred and wasnt screwed up by Shanny, then there would be no argument

No. Define scale (e.g. https://t.co/uaxKtktI ) then prescribe punishments for each.

@chrispeak1 Stuff like that is going to happen over and over again. Hell, even Giroux/Neal were "pigeonholed" to an extent

@chrispeak1 So the NHL should base all future decisions on past mistakes?

@chrispeak1 They shouldn't make the mistakes.

@chrispeak1 well they happen, that doesnt mean that in the future every decision has to be another mistake...

Write a Reply

Related Conversations

Topics Like This

Like to reply? Try Flashcards

Get notified when your questions get replies. Track your conversations.

JOIN REPLYZ

Already a Replyz Member?

Connect with Twitter

Replyz collects and amplifies questions from around the web, allowing a wider audience to answer them.

When Shanahan looks at two very, very dangerous hits, how does he weight 20 games vs. 40 vs. 50 etc.? Without scale, incredibly difficult.

But there is nuance and context within each hit. To pigeonhole discipline is to ignore the details that separate the violations

This would be tantamount to determining power play length based on the violation. Simply unfair.

Didn't you call people who said he would get suspended, idiots?

@chrispeak1 its easier to pigeon hole and spew fallacy in 136 characters and get a rise out of people. Let him do that.

No, I'm not advocating eye-for-an-eye; hate when people advance that notion. I'm saying each hit deserves independent appraisal

@937TeenWolf Exactly! if the Weber hit never occurred and wasnt screwed up by Shanny, then there would be no argument

No. Define scale (e.g. https://t.co/uaxKtktI ) then prescribe punishments for each.

@chrispeak1 Stuff like that is going to happen over and over again. Hell, even Giroux/Neal were "pigeonholed" to an extent

@chrispeak1 So the NHL should base all future decisions on past mistakes?

@chrispeak1 They shouldn't make the mistakes.

@chrispeak1 well they happen, that doesnt mean that in the future every decision has to be another mistake...

Write a Reply

Related Conversations

Topics Like This

Like to reply? Try Flashcards

Ask a question, Start a discussion, Or post anything you want to get replies to.

It’s that simple.

Start a Conversation, Get Replies